| The Mighty Bowser #71411 | $145.97 | $202.50 | $279.75 | — |
| Nintendo Entertainment System #71374 | $142.50 | $245.00 | $396.02 | — |
| Donkey Kong Arcade #72051 | $131.28 | $157.00 | $170.54 | — |
| Super Mario 64 Question Mark Block #71395 | $96.45 | $140.00 | $247.48 | — |
| Mario & Standard Kart #72037 | $95.00 | $97.90 | $121.61 | — |
| Mario Kart Luigi & Mach 8 #72050 | $90.00 | $100.00 | $144.30 | — |
| Super Mario World: Mario & Yoshi #71438 | $54.25 | $73.81 | $108.00 | — |
| Mario Kart - Spiny Shell #40787 | $51.50 | $79.99 | $94.99 | — |
| Bowser's Castle #72039 | $48.00 | $59.99 | $67.95 | — |
| Prince Florian & Castle Bowser #72042 | $47.50 | $66.04 | $79.49 | — |
| Diddy Kong's Mine Cart Ride #71425 | $38.99 | $62.81 | $71.25 | — |
| Dry Bowser Castle Battle #71423 | $37.07 | $129.00 | $177.99 | — |
| Super Mario Bundle Pack #66677 | $30.01 | — | $46.81 | — |
| Bowser's Castle Boss Battle #71369 | $30.00 | $63.56 | $98.19 | — |
| Bowser's Airship #71391 | $29.99 | $67.85 | $88.00 | — |
| Peach's Castle #71408 | $28.59 | $70.53 | $90.40 | — |
| King Boo's Haunted Mansion #71436 | $27.76 | $64.55 | $99.54 | — |
| Fire Mario #71370 | $27.02 | $38.94 | $66.07 | — |
| Piranha Plant Power-Up Pursuit #72044 | $25.99 | $18.65 | $31.09 | — |
| The Bowser Express Train #71437 | $25.01 | $88.00 | $129.99 | — |
| Battle With Roy At Peach's Castle #71435 | $24.60 | $37.19 | $50.00 | — |
| Cat Mario #71372 | $23.98 | $34.15 | $49.99 | — |
| Big Bad Island #71412 | $23.57 | $46.09 | $56.20 | — |
| Propeller Mario #71371 | $21.76 | $25.13 | $38.50 | — |
| Luigi's Mansion: Entryway #71399 | $20.60 | $50.68 | $72.07 | — |
| Toad's Special Hideaway #77907 | $20.06 | $22.65 | $32.50 | — |
| Mario Kart – Donkey Kong & DK Jumbo #72033 | $20.00 | $21.59 | $35.98 | — |
| Fliprus Snow Adventure #71417 | $19.99 | $27.06 | $37.20 | — |
| Peach's Garden Balloon Ride #71419 | $19.99 | $19.04 | $31.74 | — |
| Mario Kart – Baby Peach & Grand Prix Set #72036 | $19.92 | $38.53 | $47.99 | — |
| Creativity Toolbox #71418 | $19.41 | $32.00 | $38.23 | — |
| Party At Toad's House #72041 | $19.18 | $11.99 | $19.99 | — |
| Sealed Character Pack [Series 6] #66749 | $18.95 | — | $39.99 | — |
| Penguin Mario #71384 | $18.69 | $31.95 | $40.58 | — |
| Master Your Adventure #71380 | $18.02 | $29.82 | $39.99 | — |
| Tanooki Mario #71385 | $17.95 | $25.00 | $39.79 | — |
| Guarded Fortress #71362 | $16.97 | $25.00 | $31.00 | — |
| Luigi's Mansion: Haunt-and-Seek #71401 | $16.83 | $94.50 | $150.00 | — |
| Adventures With Interactive LEGO Peach #71441 | $16.58 | $26.96 | $29.92 | — |
| Interactive LEGO Mario & Standard Kart #72043 | $16.22 | $23.25 | $33.41 | — |
| Soda Jungle Maker Set #71434 | $16.00 | $24.85 | $42.67 | — |
| Larry's and Morton's Airships #71427 | $15.27 | $125.40 | $163.22 | — |
| Monty Mole & Super Mushroom #40414 | $15.10 | $24.99 | $35.37 | — |
| Ice Mario Suit and Frozen World #71415 | $15.00 | $35.00 | $46.94 | — |
| Reznor Knockdown #71390 | $15.00 | $25.54 | $28.99 | — |
| Builder Mario #71373 | $14.99 | $19.77 | $26.51 | — |
| Mario Kart – Toad's Garage #72035 | $14.87 | $19.27 | $26.21 | — |
| Donkey Kong's Tree House #71424 | $14.43 | $38.49 | $45.00 | — |
| Adventures With Interactive LEGO Mario #71439 | $14.22 | $26.03 | $35.00 | — |
| Big Spike's Cloudtop Challenge #71409 | $14.15 | $26.25 | $34.00 | — |
| King Boo and the Haunted Yard #71377 | $13.98 | $25.00 | $36.50 | — |
| Wiggler's Poison Swamp #71383 | $13.80 | $22.23 | $27.14 | — |
| Bee Mario #71393 | $13.47 | $14.99 | $24.94 | — |
| Bowser’s Muscle Car #71431 | $12.64 | $19.95 | $28.19 | — |
| Dorrie’s Sunken Shipwreck Adventure #71432 | $12.53 | $45.00 | $75.99 | — |
| Sealed Character Pack [Series 5] #71410 | $12.40 | $12.99 | $20.00 | — |
| Wario & King Boo #72038 | $12.07 | — | $25.49 | — |
| Frog Mario #71392 | $12.00 | $15.99 | $23.99 | — |
| Luigi's Mansion: Lab and Poltergust #71397 | $12.00 | $85.00 | $105.48 | — |
| Adventures With Interactive LEGO Luigi #71440 | $11.96 | $27.00 | $39.99 | — |
| Thwomp Drop #71376 | $11.25 | $25.90 | $27.50 | — |
| Picnic at Mario's House #71422 | $11.04 | $15.01 | $20.84 | — |
| Lava Wave Ride #71416 | $10.86 | $16.80 | $25.01 | — |
| Adventures with Luigi #71387 | $10.70 | $28.57 | $32.00 | — |
| Big Urchin Beach Ride #71400 | $10.37 | $27.60 | $40.60 | — |
| Cat Peach Suit and Frozen Tower #71407 | $10.00 | $35.00 | $45.00 | — |
| Lakitu Sky World #71389 | $10.00 | $19.99 | $25.00 | — |
| Mario Kart – Baby Mario Vs. Baby Luigi #72034 | $9.99 | $14.00 | $20.31 | — |
| Yoshi's Gift House #71406 | $9.56 | $16.36 | $21.99 | — |
| Adventures with Mario #71360 | $9.49 | $20.98 | $32.49 | — |
| Toad's Treasure Hunt #71368 | $9.41 | $25.00 | $32.00 | — |
| Captain Toad's Camp #72040 | $9.32 | $10.00 | $12.53 | — |
| Mario Kart – Standard Kart #72032 | $8.98 | $11.00 | $12.46 | — |
| Dixie Kong's Jungle Jam #71421 | $8.51 | $14.77 | $15.00 | — |
| Piranha Plant Power Slide #71365 | $8.50 | $11.12 | $24.37 | — |
| Fuzzy Flippers #71405 | $8.00 | $15.50 | $16.80 | — |
| Toad Pit Crew #30702 | — | — | $7.99 | — |
| Sealed Character Pack #71410 | $7.90 | $9.99 | $15.00 | — |
| Adventures with Peach #71403 | $7.81 | $26.99 | $32.62 | — |
| Mario Kart – Yoshi Bike #72031 | $7.65 | $11.81 | $12.03 | — |
| Piranha Plant #71426 | $7.50 | $25.00 | $40.00 | — |
| Penguin Family Snow Adventure #71430 | $6.64 | $19.11 | $25.05 | — |
| Piranha Plant Puzzling Challenge #71382 | $6.60 | $13.21 | $24.50 | — |
| Desert Pokey #71363 | $6.50 | $17.95 | $19.99 | — |
| Shy Guy & P-Wing #72045 | $6.32 | $20.42 | $20.65 | — |
| Boss Sumo Bro Topple Tower #71388 | $6.00 | $9.99 | $12.00 | — |
| Chain Chomp Jungle Encounter #71381 | $5.56 | $12.05 | $24.99 | — |
| Boomer Bill Barrage #71366 | $5.50 | $9.50 | $24.99 | — |
| Conkdor's Noggin Bopper #71414 | $5.43 | $9.00 | $15.99 | — |
| Dorrie's Beachfront #71398 | $5.00 | $15.50 | $21.99 | — |
| Goombas' Playground #71433 | $5.00 | $10.54 | $13.98 | — |
| Nabbit at Toad's Shop #71429 | $5.00 | $13.79 | $21.02 | — |
| Sealed Character Pack [Series 2] #71386 | $4.99 | $8.18 | $11.97 | — |
| Sealed Character Pack [Series 4] #71402 | $4.99 | $4.80 | $8.00 | — |
| Whomp's Lava Trouble #71364 | $4.75 | $11.99 | $16.66 | — |
| Mario's House & Yoshi #71367 | $4.34 | $12.66 | $14.50 | — |
| Yoshis' Egg-cellent Forest #71428 | $4.25 | $8.99 | $10.43 | — |
| Bowser Jr.'s Clown Car #71396 | $4.14 | $10.99 | $20.45 | — |
| Sealed Character Pack [Series 3] #71394 | $4.09 | $9.27 | $10.05 | — |
| Sealed Character Pack [Series 1] #71361 | $4.00 | $10.58 | $14.94 | — |
| Sealed Character Pack [Series 6] #71413 | $3.99 | $9.48 | $9.99 | — |
| Rambi the Rhino #71420 | $3.52 | $4.63 | $10.49 | — |
| Fuzzy & Mushroom Platform #30389 | $3.40 | $4.06 | $8.74 | — |
| Yellow Yoshi's Fruit Tree #30509 | $3.25 | $5.57 | $6.25 | — |
| Super Mushroom Surprise #30385 | $2.99 | $3.62 | $4.24 | — |
| Goomba's Shoe #71404 | $1.33 | $8.60 | $11.85 | — |