Nightmare
The Nightmare (Alpha) sells for around $883.98 ungraded.

In short
The Nightmare (Alpha) sells for around $883.98 ungraded. Tracked daily since Nov 12, 2026.
Prices as of Nov 16, 2026.
The story
Alpha Nightmare, a black creature whose strength depends on the Swamps you control
Nightmare is a black creature in Magic: The Gathering. Its size depends on how many Swamps its controller has, so it grows in heavy black decks. Wizards of the Coast printed this version in Alpha in 1993.
The tracker shows Ungraded at $884 and PSA 9 at $3,476. It ranks #116 of 23430 Magic items by value and #44 of 294 in Alpha. The gap from raw to PSA 9 is wide, so condition drives the price.
Before you buy
- Check the set on the listing and on any slab label.
- Look at edges and corners in photos of raw copies.
Sources
- PriceCharting — ungraded / graded sold-price guide, snapshotted daily · fetched Nov 16, 2026
Every number on this page comes from these public sources, collected and checked by Sort Brick.
Get Sort Brick Daily - free, every evening
One short email every evening: what really moved, what was only noise, and what we logged first, with the times. Free. Information, not investment advice.