Butterfree #2
Butterfree #2 from Fire Red & Leaf Green is worth about $40.46 ungraded.

In short
Butterfree #2 from Fire Red & Leaf Green is worth about $40.46 ungraded. A PSA 10 copy goes for $2,500 — 61.8× the ungraded price. Tracked daily since Nov 11, 2026.
Prices as of Nov 16, 2026.
The story
Butterfree from the Fire Red & Leaf Green remake set, built on a wide grade gap
Butterfree #2 comes from Fire Red & Leaf Green, the EX-era set themed on the Game Boy Advance remakes of the original Kanto games. Butterfree is one of the recognisable Kanto Pokemon, so the card draws attention from nostalgia collectors as well as set builders.
This is the plain version of the card, with no reverse holo, stamp or edition label attached to it. Because there is no special tag, its price comes from the card itself and from how well a copy grades.
The price ladder is steep. Ungraded copies sit at $40.42, PSA 9 at $224 and PSA 10 at $2,500. The jump to a PSA 10 is large, which shows how much the market pays for a flawless copy of this EX-era card. It ranks #41 of 219 in its set by value.
Before you buy
- Look closely at the edges and corners; EX-era cards show whitening easily, and that decides PSA 9 versus PSA 10.
- Check centering front and back before paying a graded-level price for a raw copy.
- If buying graded, confirm the label's card number and name match the card in the slab.
Sources
- PriceCharting — ungraded / graded sold-price guide, snapshotted daily · fetched Nov 16, 2026
Every number on this page comes from these public sources, collected and checked by Sort Brick.
Get Sort Brick Daily - free, every evening
One short email every evening: what really moved, what was only noise, and what we logged first, with the times. Free. Information, not investment advice.