Start 7-day free trial
Pokémon · Neo Genesis

Feraligatr [1st Edition] #5

The Feraligatr [1st Edition] #5 (Neo Genesis) sells for around $261.82 ungraded.

Feraligatr [1st Edition] #5
Ungraded
$261.82
PSA 9
$2,562
PSA 10
$4,531
1 day
▲ +2.3%
7 days
▲ +9.0%
30 days
▲ +67.6%

In short

The Feraligatr [1st Edition] #5 (Neo Genesis) sells for around $261.82 ungraded. A PSA 10 copy goes for $4,531 — 17.3× the ungraded price. Price up 9.0% over 7 days, up 67.6% over 30 days. Tracked daily since Jun 22, 2026.

Prices as of Nov 16, 2026.

The story

1st Edition Feraligatr from Neo Genesis, where PSA 9 is $3,100 and PSA 10 only $4,531

This is the 1st Edition printing of Feraligatr from Neo Genesis, a Wizards of the Coast set built around the Johto Pokemon. Feraligatr is the final form of the water starter Totodile.

The 1st Edition name marks the first print run of the set, which carried a stamp that later printings do not. Collectors look for it because the early print run is the version they care about most.

The prices tell the story. Ungraded is $240, PSA 9 is $3,100 and PSA 10 is $4,531. The gap between PSA 9 and PSA 10 is small next to the gap from raw to PSA 9, so the main step is getting any good grade at all. The card is #21 of 222 in the set by value and #1350 of 38402 in the category.

Franchise
Pokemon
Series
Neo Genesis
Character
Feraligatr
Printing
1st Edition

Before you buy

  • Check that the 1st Edition stamp is present and looks like the stamps on known genuine copies.
  • Look at the card edges and corners carefully, as the Neo era cards wear easily.
Price history, grade premium and alerts for Feraligatr [1st Edition] #5Live data, filters and alerts in the app · Start a 7-day free trial — then $39/mo, cancel anytime
Open the live page →Start 7-day free trial

Sources

  • PriceCharting — ungraded / graded sold-price guide, snapshotted daily · fetched Nov 16, 2026

Every number on this page comes from these public sources, collected and checked by Sort Brick.

Get Sort Brick Daily - free, every evening

One short email every evening: what really moved, what was only noise, and what we logged first, with the times. Free. Information, not investment advice.

No spam. One click to unsubscribe. Sent by Sort Brick.