Feraligatr #5
Feraligatr #5 from Neo Genesis is worth about $79.99 ungraded.

In short
Feraligatr #5 from Neo Genesis is worth about $79.99 ungraded. A PSA 10 copy goes for $8,067 — 100.9× the ungraded price. Price down 0.9% over 7 days, up 14.3% over 30 days. Tracked daily since Jun 22, 2026.
Prices as of Nov 16, 2026.
The story
Neo Genesis Feraligatr, the Johto Water starter holo that reaches $8,067 at PSA 10
Feraligatr is card number 5 in Neo Genesis, the Wizards of the Coast set that opened the Johto generation for English-language collectors in 2000. It is the final evolution of Totodile, the Water starter of the Johto games, and sits in the set beside the Chikorita and Cyndaquil lines.
This is the standard Neo Genesis printing. Cards from this era have a reputation for soft edges and holo surfaces that pick up scratches, so a clean copy takes some finding, and centering on the Neo layout is often uneven.
Ungraded is $80.73, PSA 9 is $557 and PSA 10 is $8,067. The leap from PSA 9 to PSA 10 is where most of the value sits. It ranks #13 of 222 in its set by value and #768 of 38401 across the category.
Before you buy
- Tilt the card under a light and look for scratches across the holo and whitening on the edges.
- Confirm the set symbol and number before relying on slab prices.
- Verify the slab certificate number with the grading company.
Sources
- PriceCharting — ungraded / graded sold-price guide, snapshotted daily · fetched Nov 16, 2026
Every number on this page comes from these public sources, collected and checked by Sort Brick.
Get Sort Brick Daily - free, every evening
One short email every evening: what really moved, what was only noise, and what we logged first, with the times. Free. Information, not investment advice.